Andrew Williams, Every Time I Die guitarist known to wrestling fans as ‘The Butcher,’ dies

Andrew Williams, widely recognized for his role as rhythm guitarist in the metalcore band Every Time I Die and for his wrestling persona “The Butcher,” has passed away, as confirmed by All Elite Wrestling (AEW).

Williams collapsed during an independent wrestling event in Millvale, Pennsylvania, on a Saturday night and was immediately attended to by onsite medical personnel before being transported to a hospital. The promoter of the event stated that emergency measures, including CPR, were administered at the scene, but details about the cause of death have not been disclosed.

Born and raised around Buffalo, New York, Williams had initially expected to follow a working-class path similar to his family, who were employed in factory jobs. However, his passion for music led him to pick up the guitar despite challenges with learning disabilities such as dyslexia, which hindered his ability to read musical notation. He found an intuitive connection to playing guitar, which propelled him into a long career in music.

Williams co-founded Every Time I Die in 1998 and remained a key member until the band’s dissolution in 2022. The band earned acclaim for blending intense, chaotic energy with melodic hooks, gaining a dedicated following and signing with Epitaph Records in 2008. After the breakup of Every Time I Die, Williams continued his musical pursuits with a new project named Atomic Rule, which released a demo EP in 2025. Just hours before his collapse, Williams posted a video on social media announcing the completion of new material and an upcoming tour alongside the band Gwar scheduled for late 2026.

Parallel to his music career, Williams nurtured a deep affection for professional wrestling. It was not until attending an indie wrestling show in Southern California around 2014 that he seriously considered entering the sport himself. Beginning his wrestling career at 37, he adopted the moniker “The Butcher,” becoming known for his imposing presence and aggressive style. He gained wider exposure through AEW, appearing on televised matches from 2019 until his contract concluded in 2026.

Williams often reflected on the artistic similarities between songwriting and wrestling, noting the narrative structures and emotional dynamics shared by both crafts. Despite his dual careers, those close to him emphasized his genuine nature, humility, and desire to bring joy to friends and colleagues rather than seeking fame or ego.

Tributes poured in from a range of musicians and wrestlers following news of his death. Fellow artists remembered Williams for his kindness and the unexpected combination of his musical talent and wrestling persona. AEW colleagues highlighted his intellect and warmth, often contrasting his tough exterior with his considerate character. Several wrestling figures noted his mentorship and support for emerging talent within the industry.

Williams’ influence spanned two demanding worlds, creating a legacy marked by dedication and versatility. His passing has been mourned deeply by fans and peers who admired his contributions both on stage and in the ring. As the community reflects on his multifaceted career, further details about the circumstances surrounding his death remain limited.

Andrew Williams leaves behind a unique imprint as an artist who defied conventional boundaries, merging the intensity of metalcore music with the physical storytelling of professional wrestling. His work continues to resonate through the music he helped create and the wrestling persona he embodied.