All 4 Every Time I Die Members Share Andy Williams Tributes

The music and wrestling communities are mourning the loss of Andy Williams, the guitarist and co-founder of the influential metalcore band Every Time I Die, who passed away unexpectedly at age 48. Williams died over the weekend during a wrestling event in Pennsylvania, where he was actively pursuing a career alongside his musical pursuits.

Williams, alongside brothers Keith and Jordan Buckley, helped establish Every Time I Die in 1998. The band, known for its intense sound and passionate fanbase, disbanded in 2022 amid internal conflicts. Despite the split, Williams’ former bandmates have individually expressed profound grief and admiration for his impact, both personally and professionally.

Keith Buckley, the band’s former vocalist, shared a reflective tribute recalling a moment that exemplified Williams’ inclusive spirit. He recounted a childhood fascination with a local truck stop that symbolized the diverse lives people lead—a metaphor for the way Williams made others feel welcome and part of a community. Keith described how Williams’ genuine warmth extended to strangers and friends alike, often staying behind after shows to connect with fans and crew, making everyone feel valued.

Jordan Buckley, the band’s guitarist, highlighted Williams’ kindness and generosity through a story from their time on the Warped Tour. Williams had once proposed attempting to break a Guinness World Record for the most hugs given at the Chicago stop, reflecting his desire to spread affection and joy, even if the attempt was ultimately denied for logistical reasons. Jordan expressed his deep sorrow and the enduring influence Williams has on those who knew him.

Stephen Micciche, bassist for Every Time I Die, shared poignant memories of a recent lunch with Williams just weeks before his passing. He reflected on Williams’ vibrant energy and creative drive, noting the guitarist’s ability to inspire everyone around him. Micciche described Williams as a brother-like figure whose passion extended beyond music into wrestling, where he pursued his childhood dream starting at age 35. He also mentioned the band’s final recording, a cover of Cave In's "Youth Overrided," symbolizing their lasting bond.

Drummer Clayton "Goose" Holyoak echoed the sentiments of his bandmates, emphasizing Williams’ mix of kindness and adventurous spirit. He recalled how Williams defied expectations, including those of a former music teacher who doubted his musical future. Holyoak praised Williams’ relentless pursuit of his goals and his talent for making anyone he met feel included and appreciated.

Williams’ death occurred during a wrestling show in Pennsylvania, where reports indicate he collapsed and struck his head after a match. Medical staff on site responded immediately, administering CPR before paramedics arrived. He was transported to Allegheny General Hospital but was pronounced dead shortly after midnight. Initial assessments suggested a cardiac event, though official cause remains pending autopsy results.

The wrestling community also paid tribute to Williams. Notably, wrestler Malakai Black dedicated his Progress Wrestling World Championship victory to Williams, speaking emotionally about their friendship and inviting the crowd to honor Williams with a final cheer.

Musicians outside Every Time I Die have also acknowledged Williams’ influence. During a My Chemical Romance concert in Phoenix, the band dedicated a song to Williams, referred to by his wrestling nickname, "The Butcher," underscoring his impact beyond his original band.

Williams’ passing marks the loss of a multifaceted artist who bridged the worlds of hardcore music and professional wrestling with fervor and authenticity. His bandmates’ reflections reveal a man who lived with an open heart, inspiring those around him to embrace community, creativity, and courage. As tributes continue to emerge, his legacy endures in the music he helped create and the lives he touched.